Over the waist limit at your screening? Your options
If your reward depends on meeting a waist result, the plan must give you another way to earn the same, full reward. Federal wellness rules call this a reasonable alternative standard. The plan has to tell you it exists, and your own doctor can ask for it to be adjusted.
Which programs this covers
The rules apply to health-contingent wellness programs in group health plans: ones where the reward depends on a health result, such as a waist under 40 inches, or on an activity tied to a health factor. Programs that reward you simply for taking part, for example for attending the screening whatever the result, work differently and do not need an alternative.
For outcome-based programs, the 2013 final rules issued by the Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services and the Treasury say:
- An alternative for everyone who misses the result. The plan must offer a reasonable alternative standard to all individuals who do not meet the initial health-related standard.
- The same reward. Someone who qualifies through the alternative must get the same, full reward as someone who met the original standard.
- It must be disclosed. Program materials, and any notice saying you did not meet the standard, must mention the alternative.
- Your doctor’s say. If your personal physician says the alternative is not medically appropriate for you, the plan must accommodate your physician’s recommendations.
- A cap on the reward. Generally no more than 30% of the cost of employee-only coverage, or 50% when the program targets tobacco use.
What to do if you are over the line
- Read the notice. Find the alternative it describes and the deadline to request or complete it.
- Ask questions early. Your HR or benefits team, or the wellness vendor, can explain what the alternative involves and how to show you have met it.
- Talk to your doctor if the alternative does not fit. Their recommendation must be accommodated.
- Start measuring. Many alternatives involve progress over months. A dated record of your waist, measured the same way each time, helps you, your coach and your doctor see whether it is working.
This page explains the federal rules in general terms. Your plan’s documents and your benefits team decide how they apply to you, and state rules or other laws may add to them.
Why the waist line is there
The NIH’s National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute says a waist of more than 40 inches for men or more than 35 inches for women increases the risk of heart disease and type 2 diabetes. It is a screening signal, not a diagnosis. For how screeners measure it and a checker for your own reading, see biometric screening waist measurement.
Questions people ask
Can my employer charge me more for a large waist?
A group health plan can tie a reward, such as a premium discount, to a health result like waist size, within limits. The reward generally cannot exceed 30% of the cost of coverage (50% for tobacco programs), and the plan must offer a reasonable alternative standard to anyone who does not meet the result.
What is a reasonable alternative standard?
Another way to earn the same reward if you do not meet the health result, for example completing a coaching program, following a plan agreed with your doctor, or showing progress. The plan must mention it in its program materials and in any notice telling you that you did not meet the standard.
Do I get the full reward if I meet the alternative?
Yes. Under the 2013 final rules, someone who qualifies through a reasonable alternative standard must receive the same, full reward as someone who met the original standard.
Can my own doctor change what the plan asks me to do?
Yes. If your personal physician says the plan’s alternative is not medically appropriate for you, the plan must accommodate your physician’s recommendations.
Your body in 3D
See where you are starting from
An alternative standard usually means showing progress over months. Add your height, weight and waist to see your starting body, the one you will compare against later.
This preview is an estimate from a parametric 3D body model. It is not a body scan or a medical assessment.
What you can measure. All on one body.
- Weight
- Neck
- Chest
- Waist
- Thigh
- Shoulder girth
- Arm
- Wrist
- Hip
- Calf
Left and right · Your own spots
Turn it around in the app
In Contura this body turns any way you like. Log your measurements each week and it changes with you, so you can put any two dates side by side.
Download ConturaSources
- Incentives for Nondiscriminatory Wellness Programs in Group Health Plans (final rules) Departments of Labor, Health and Human Services and the Treasury, Federal Register, 3 June 2013
- Heart-Healthy Living: Aim for a Healthy Weight (Measuring waist circumference) National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute (NIH), last updated 11 December 2025
Contura